The hunt for Green October

The hunt for Green October

by Ben Acheson
article from Monday 8, October, 2012

THE SINGLE MOST important duty of any government is to ensure national security; the protection of its citizens. Economic prosperity, health, education and energy security are vital to the success of any democratic state, but national security should be any government's first priority.

In an increasingly globalised world, the UK faces an ever-changing range of security threats from widely varying sources. New threats increasingly emanate from non-state actors. Insurgency, cyber attacks and terrorism provide unprecedented tests for our national security architecture. Nuclear proliferation is another growing danger even though today's concept of national security differs vastly from when we dealt with the 'conventional' threats of the Cold War era. Britain will forever be an island nation, however, and the Royal Navy therefore has a vital role to play in providing national security, regardless of the threat.

Enter the submarine.

The Royal Navy Submarine Service has helped protect our waters since 1901 and today, the 'Silent Service' consists of two classes of Fleet submarines and one class of Ballistic Missile submarines. The Fleet submarines include the five Trafalgar class subs and one Astute class vessel. These hunter-killer subs are nuclear powered and armed with Spearfish Torpedos and Tomahawk cruise missiles.

The Navy's four ballistic missile subs are all of the Vanguard class. They are the UK's nuclear deterrent and use the Trident missile system. For over 30 years, there has been at least one of these vessels on patrol at all times. Each one of the ballistic submarines carries one of the four, identically worded, 'letters of last resort' which are handwritten by the Prime Minister and contain orders about what action is to be taken in the event that the UK has been devastated by a nuclear strike, in which case the subs may be the last military force standing.

Scotland is the home of the strategic nuclear deterrent. Her Majesty's Naval Base Clyde, which consists of the Faslane Naval Base and the Armament Depot at Coulport, is the home of the UK's Astute and Vanguard class submarines. Worryingly, there is a new threat facing these vessels. But this threat does not come from a hostile state, a foreign insurgent or even a homegrown terrorist. This threat comes from our own government.

As part of the SNP's plans to encase Scotland's coast with wind turbines, two enormous areas in the Firth of Clyde have been earmarked as 'Strategic Search Areas' for massive offshore wind arrays. If plans for turbines are consented, the two zones, named 'West of Ayrshire' and 'South of Islay', could be home to two of the world's largest wind farms. The South of Islay zone consists of a gigantic 1,284km2 (496 sq miles) area which would effectively close most of the entrance to the Firth of Clyde. The 'West of Ayrshire' zone is a 301km2 (116 sq miles) area just off the coast, which would prevent access even further. In comparison, the world's current largest offshore wind farm, the planned array in the Moray Firth, will cover 300km2 (114 sq miles).

For the submarines, which leave Gareloch and travel down Faslane Bay, through the Rhu Narrows and into the Firth of Clyde, the consequences are worrying. These silent hunters are designed to be stealthy, versatile and lethal. They rely heavily on silence. The onboard 'sound room' is home to all of the sonar equipment - the ears of the submarine. Here, up to 12 sonar operators use high-tech machinery to listen to the outside world to collect information vital to the creation of the tactical systems picture. Sound is the principal means of working out what or who else, friend or foe, is in the ocean.

As sound is so vital to these submarines, the sonar equipment is not your regular run-of-the-mill kit that is installed in many fishing boats. These submarines have the most advanced sonar systems in the world. They detect every noise the ocean makes, even biological sounds from tiny shrimp to dolphins and whales. Identifying biological noise is a vital job for the sound operators as whales are so large that they could be mistaken for other submarines due to the flow noise created by their smooth bodies, which sounds similar to submarines.

The sonar equipment on these submarines can not only identify other vessels up to 70 miles away, but it can tell you how many shafts and blades their propellers have. Astoundingly, it can even tell how fast the other vessel is travelling and what type of machinery is on board the ship. The submariners keep a record of every technical detail of vessels they meet so they know if they come across the same ship again, even years later.

These silent hunters, with over £200 million of hardware, lurk undetected in our waters. They listen and watch everything, without anyone knowing, ready to intercept and attack at a moment's notice. They are unsung heroes and most of us will never know just how important they are. Needless to say, surrounding their home base and most of the coast of Scotland with massive, noisy, industrial wind turbines will not only hamper the navigational ability of the subs, but could completely ruin their ability to detect and intercept hostile ships and submarines.

With their support for onshore wind power, we saw how the SNP hijacked energy policy as a means for its own political gain. Now the government's aim to appear 'green' is trumping the protection of its citizens. Is the Government's plans for vast offshore wind farms another step towards achieving its main political goal? Is this is all part of the plan to rid Scotland of the UK’s nuclear deterrent and clear the path towards independence?

ThinkScotland exists thanks to readers' support - please donate in any currency and often

Follow us on Facebook and Twitter & like and share this article

User Comments

Another poorly researched article aimed at scaremongering. I think the Uk government has already "encased" the British Isles with " these damned un English" weapons of mass energy generation, so don't worry about the soon to be Scottish government getting in on the act too. As for the submarine element to this poorly researched article I do not understand what you are waffling about. Are you saying that due to wind farms Royal Navy Submarines are now in danger of not hearing the " enemy" have a little faith the Royal Navy are well practiced at hearing things with their submarines and I'm sure a few shallow water wind farms where subs can't actually operate are the least of the Royal Navy's problems. More worrying is the inability of the Royal Navy to keep their submarines from going aground ie HMS Astute off the coast of Skye a few years ago. I'm Scottish love the Royal Navy can't stand Salmond , want Independence and a nuclear deterrent and think this article is rubbish, confused ?? Me too ! !

Posted on Monday 8, October, 2012 by Malcolm Dowie
A paranoid article and disappointing assessment of the waning relevance of the Trident system. "National security" is arguably the main driving force behind why many people will vote for independence, taking a principal led break from the insecurity caused by being annexed to UK and US foreign policy should in itself automatically guarantee it somewhat. Granted, "nsurgency, cyber attacks and terrorism provide unprecedented tests for our national security architecture" but these kinds of changes in threat render nuclear armed submarines redundant, a costly legacy of the Cold War world. Nuclear proliferation is being directly caused by the nuclear states failure to adhere to their obligations to disarm and make meaningful advances in the global political arena, advances that will undoubtedly require taking a long, stern look in the mirror. Proposals for a replacement of the Trident system are increasingly encroached upon by private companies, BAE Systems, Babcock, RollsRoyce, to name but a few. Are we to believe that these profit driven companies are acting in the name of national security? It's time to stop scaremongering and start actively creating the peaceful world the UK claims to aspire to.

Posted on Monday 8, October, 2012 by Don Leone
Bot just the nuclear fleet that would be affected but commercial shipping as well. No working dockas at Greenock, Port glasgow or Hunterston either. Large container ships or coaliers have a lot of momentum and are not built for manoeuvering around posts any more than large lorries are. Coal burned at Hunterston is helping keep the lights on. TYhis looks like another way of both deepening the recession and turning the lights off so one can see why the SNP like it.

Posted on Monday 8, October, 2012 by Neil Craig
There is no way of identifying hostile aircraft in wind farms so the London Array, Gunistone and Thanet have become Transponder mandatory areas. Which means aircraft transmit a code which allows air traffic to identify where they are. Will hostiles be so accommodating?

Posted on Monday 8, October, 2012 by Dougal Quixote